Will a Criminal Charge Cause Problems in Returning to the US?

Does a criminal problem stop you from returning to the US? Some crimes or unlawful acts have little to no effect on your ability to reenter the US. In contrast, others can result in detention at the airport, referral to immigration proceedings, or a permanent ban from the country. 

The specific risks depend on the offense, your immigration status, and whether you’re otherwise admissible to the US. In this post, we’ll walk you through how these factors determine outcomes, so you can avoid unexpected complications at the border. 

Potential Impact of Criminal Charges on Reentering the US

US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) officers inspect travelers entering the US at a port of entry. During the CBP inspection, officers may check criminal records, pending charges, prior convictions, and immigration history to assess whether an individual is admissible. On its own, having a criminal charge won’t automatically stop you from returning to the US. 

However, it may prompt further scrutiny and secondary inspection if more detail is necessary. Even a misdemeanor under state law can sometimes have serious immigration consequences. It’s essential to note that how a criminal charge impacts your return to the US depends on various factors, such as the following: 

  • Your immigration status
  • The type and seriousness of the crime
  • Whether the offense falls under a specific ground of inadmissibility

Crimes That Can Put Your Immigration Status at Risk

Not all criminal offenses result in the same immigration consequences. The Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) outlines several grounds of inadmissibility for noncitizens who commit certain criminal and related offenses. 

Even if you already hold a green card, you must prove that you’re admissible when seeking to come to the US. Otherwise, you may be refused entry at the border. In particular, Section 212 of the INA lists the grounds that can make a foreign national inadmissible. 

Inadmissibility can apply even without a criminal conviction. It may also apply if you admit to facts that establish every legal element of the crime, even without saying outright that you committed it. That’s why discussing past conduct during a consular interview or at a port of entry can be risky without immigration counsel.

Unless an exception applies, both criminal convictions and certain admissions can create problems in returning to the US for the following categories of offenses: 

Crimes involving moral turpitude (CIMTs)

These offenses involve dishonesty, fraud, deception, or conduct that goes against accepted standards of morality. Examples commonly include certain theft, fraud, and assault-related offenses. 

Notably, immigration consequences may apply not only when you complete a CIMT, but also when you attempt or conspire to commit one. However, this category generally excludes purely political offenses.

Controlled substance violations

Controlled substance violations are another major category that can trigger immigration problems. Certain drug offenses, whether they violate local, state, or international laws, can prevent you from entering the country. 

That means a drug offense does not have to occur within the US to create immigration consequences. Suppose you committed a controlled substance violation in another country. It can still affect your ability to return to the US, particularly if it involves a conviction or a qualifying admission.

What This Means for Different Immigration Statuses

Immigration law is not a one-size-fits-all system. Because it does not apply the same standards to everyone crossing the US border, the impact of a criminal charge depends largely on an individual’s immigration status. 

As a result, those seeking to reenter the US can face different outcomes even with the same criminal history. It’s essential, then, to understand how your immigration status affects your ability to return to the US before making any international travel plans. 

US citizens

US citizens are subject to inspection at the ports of entry. CBP officers can identify outstanding warrants or other unresolved criminal issues. But generally, a criminal charge or conviction cannot solely bar US citizens from reentering the country. Although they can be detained for an existing valid arrest or other enforcement action, US citizens retain the right to return to the US. 

Lawful permanent residents

Lawful permanent residents (LPRs) are legally entitled to reside and work in the US. However, holding a green card does not automatically guarantee reentry to the country after every trip abroad. 

Certain criminal convictions can place a green card holder’s status in jeopardy. They can trigger either inadmissibility at the border or removability after entry, depending on the specific offense and circumstance. Either one can result in additional questioning, detention, or a referral to immigration court upon return to the US.

Temporary visa holders

Temporary visa holders have fewer protections than LPRs, which is why they often face higher immigration risks following a criminal arrest or conviction. Depending on the offense, a criminal record could cost noncitizens with temporary lawful status their current visa, block them from returning to the US, or disqualify them from future immigration benefits. 

Talk Through Your Immigration Situation With ALG Lawyers

Green card holders with a prior or pending arrest or criminal conviction face a greater risk when traveling internationally. Before making travel plans, it’s worth speaking with a qualified Los Angeles immigration lawyer to protect your status and better understand your legal options. 

Our legal team at ALG Lawyers can evaluate your criminal history for inadmissibility concerns, explore waiver or relief options, and assist you in preparing the necessary documentation for international travel. Call us today to talk through your immigration situation. 

FAQs on Will a Criminal Charge Cause Problems in Returning to the US

Whether you can travel abroad with a pending criminal charge depends on the specifics of your case. Bail conditions, passport status, release conditions, and court orders may restrict your ability to leave and reenter the country. 

The Visa Waiver Program (VWP) is only for travelers who are considered eligible and admissible. When you apply for ESTA, the authorization used for VWP travel, you must disclose past arrests and convictions. 

Certain criminal offenses can disqualify you from visa-free travel. In that case, you may need to apply for a visa and a waiver of inadmissibility. Still, it’s worth noting that the ultimate decision on admissibility rests with the border officials at the port of entry. 

Unlike lawful permanent residents, US citizens are not subject to an inadmissibility determination. That means their ability to enter the country cannot be questioned or denied based on criminal history, prior violations, or other grounds of admissibility. However, they may still be inspected and required to prove their US citizenship at the port of entry.

(Please note that this article does not create an Attorney-Client relationship between our law firm and the reader and is provided for informational purposes only. Information in this article does not apply to all readers. Readers should not rely on this information as legal advice and should seek specific counsel from a qualified attorney based on their individual circumstances. Thank you.)